Skip to content
Insights · For owners, managers & GCs · Post 9 of 10

Carrier Forms vs. ISO Forms: Why the Footer Matters

Carrier proprietary endorsements can differ sharply from standard ISO forms. Owners and GCs can spot the difference in the footer before relying on the wording.

When you ask a tenant or subcontractor for their additional insured endorsement, the document you receive will fall into one of two broad categories. It will be either a standard form published by the Insurance Services Office, commonly called ISO, or a proprietary form written by the carrier itself.

The difference matters more than most owners and general contractors realize, and you can usually tell which one you are looking at in a few seconds.

What ISO forms are

ISO develops standardized policy forms and endorsements used across the property and casualty industry. Its additional insured endorsements are widely used, well documented, and have been interpreted by courts for decades. When an insurance professional sees a form number such as CG 20 10 or CG 20 37, they know what the form generally says, and they can look up how the language has changed from edition to edition.

That predictability has value for everyone who relies on the endorsement.

Why carriers write their own forms

Carriers employ many attorneys. Those attorneys defend claims and handle regulatory and filing matters. They also write the language on the carrier’s proprietary forms.

Ask yourself why a carrier would invest time and money to design a form when ISO has already created one that the entire industry recognizes. The most common answer is that the carrier does not want to offer exactly what the ISO form offers.

Sometimes that means the carrier’s form is narrower, with added conditions, different definitions or tighter limits on who qualifies. Sometimes the reason is structural. A carrier that uses its own proprietary base liability policy, instead of the ISO commercial general liability form, needs endorsements written to fit that base policy. In some of those cases, the proprietary additional insured form is actually broader than the current ISO edition.

The point is not that carrier forms are always worse. The point is that you cannot assume what they say.

How to tell the difference

Look at the footer and the form number.

  • ISO forms follow a consistent numbering convention, such as CG 20 10 04 13, where the last four digits represent the edition month and year. The footer reads “© Insurance Services Office, Inc.” followed by a year.
  • Carrier proprietary forms use the carrier’s own numbering system. When they borrow ISO language, the footer typically says the form “includes copyrighted material of Insurance Services Office, Inc., with its permission.”

That second phrase is your signal. It means the form was built from ISO material but has been changed.

What small wording changes can do

When we compare an ISO additional insured endorsement for ongoing operations with a carrier’s version of the same coverage, the differences can look minor at first glance. A phrase is removed here, a condition is added there. But those small changes can materially alter the coverage. For example, a change in how the form treats the acts of the insured’s own subcontractors, or in whether coverage applies to the additional insured’s own negligence, can decide whether a claim is defended.

What this means for your review

  • Identify the form type before you evaluate the wording. ISO forms can be compared against known editions. Carrier forms need a full read.
  • Do not rely on a verbal assurance from anyone that a carrier form is “the same as ISO.” If a carrier representative will confirm that in writing, keep that writing in your file. If they will not, treat it as unconfirmed.
  • Compare against your contract. If your lease or subcontract requires a specific ISO form or its equivalent, have the carrier form reviewed to see whether it truly measures up.
  • Get help with unfamiliar forms. Proprietary endorsements are where experienced reviewers earn their keep.

Why this matters for your requirements

Many leases and subcontracts require additional insured coverage “on ISO form CG 20 10 and CG 20 37 or their equivalent.” That phrase “or their equivalent” does a lot of work. When a tenant or subcontractor provides a carrier form instead, someone has to decide whether it truly is equivalent. That decision requires comparing the actual wording, line by line, against the ISO edition your contract references.

If no one on your team is comfortable making that call, it is worth having a specialist review the forms you see most often. Over time, you will build a library of carrier forms you already know how to evaluate.

Talk to us

Questions about your insurance requirements?

Risk Associates is a New York firm with three decades of experience in contractual risk transfer and certificate of insurance compliance. We review certificates and endorsements for commercial real estate owners, property managers and contractors, and we track them, so gaps get closed before a claim. Reach out to talk through your insurance requirements.