“Don’t worry, they have blanket additional insured.”
If you manage property or run projects, you have probably heard that sentence from a tenant, a subcontractor or even their agent. It sounds reassuring. The word “blanket” suggests a wide net that catches everyone who needs to be covered.
That is not what blanket means, and misunderstanding it is one of the most common ways owners, managers and upstream contractors end up without the coverage their contracts required.
What blanket was designed to do
Before blanket endorsements, carriers had to issue a separate endorsement naming every party that a policyholder’s contracts required to be added as an additional insured. For a busy contractor, that could mean dozens or hundreds of endorsements a year.
Blanket endorsements were created to reduce that administrative burden. Instead of naming each party, the endorsement grants additional insured status automatically to parties that meet a description, usually a party the insured is required to add by a written contract.
Notice what that design goal was. It was to reduce paperwork for the carrier and the insured. It was not to expand coverage to everyone involved in a project or property.
The catch: contractual privity
Most blanket additional insured endorsements include qualifying language. You will see phrases like:
- “for whom you are performing operations”
- “with whom you have entered into a written contract or agreement”
- “from whom you lease land or premises”
- “while in the performance of your ongoing operations for that additional insured”
This wording is called contractual privity language. It limits additional insured status to the party that is actually on the other side of the insured’s contract. The party that hired the insured directly, or the landlord that signed the lease directly, may be covered. Everyone above them is not.
What that looks like on a construction project
Picture a typical project as a tower. At the top is the owner, often alongside a lender and a construction manager. Below them is the general contractor. Below the GC are the subcontractors, and below them may be sub-subcontractors.
A drywall subcontractor signs a contract with the GC. That contract requires the sub to name the owner, the GC and the construction manager as additional insureds. The sub’s policy has a blanket endorsement with privity language: coverage applies to the party “with whom you have entered into a written contract.”
The GC signed that contract, so the GC is likely covered. The owner and the construction manager did not. Even though the subcontract required them to be covered, the blanket endorsement may not reach them. These are what the industry calls upstream parties, and privity language leaves them out.
What that looks like in commercial real estate
The same issue shows up in leasing. A tenant signs a lease with a property-owning entity. The lease requires the tenant to name the owner, the property manager and perhaps the lender or an affiliated entity as additional insureds. The tenant’s policy has a blanket endorsement covering the party “from whom you lease premises.”
The landlord entity that signed the lease may be covered. The property management company, which usually is not a party to the lease, may not be. We have seen claims where a property manager was sued, tendered to the tenant’s carrier, and was denied a defense because it did not qualify under the blanket wording.
How to protect yourself
- Ask whether the endorsement is blanket or scheduled. If it is blanket, ask for a copy and read the qualifying language.
- Look for privity phrases. Any wording that ties coverage to a direct contract, a direct lease, or operations performed “for” the additional insured should get a closer look.
- Name the parties who matter. If your management company, lender or affiliated entities need coverage, your requirements should say so clearly, and you should confirm that the endorsement actually reaches them.
- Know that better forms exist. Some endorsements extend coverage to parties the insured’s direct contracting partner is required to add, which is designed for exactly this upstream problem. We cover that in more detail elsewhere in this series.